Dear Noah,

Thank you, Ed N., TN, TN, for your review of Bricktop's in Franklin, TN.
Your one-star review begins with, "Noah, our waiter was excellent, The tavern burger was fair at best." Aside from the punctuation implying that this review is written to Noah, you're using some big words (excellent, fair) that contradict the star rating you've branded onto this establishment. Then we get to words like cold and mush. Understandably, things are going downhill.
However, the review ends on a high note. "My wife like her salmon and veggies and they cook it just how she likes it and how she ordered it." In my opinion, this bodes very well for the business, especially because mentioning "how she ordered it" suggests she requires special alterations not listed on the actual menu. Yet you continue to give Bricktop's one star! Pretty petty for a place it sounds like you might patronize often. Even if you don't, ordering off menu is a cardinal sin in my book.
This has me curious about the criteria for star ratings on sites like Yelp. They've been in this business for a long time; there must be guidelines to follow when you write a review. So, I begrudingly looked into it. Here's what I found:





This could not be clearer.
So, it appears, Ed N, that you and I are at an impasse. You see, if my server, Noah, was excellent, and my wife was very happy about her food, this would at least be a two-star "Could've been better" review. Knowing me, it would have been a three-star or, better yet, no review at all. But I didn't write this review; you did, and so I have no choice but to gather all the evidence and assume something about you:
You view your needs as more important than your wife's.
Everything that went wrong with your dish trumped the positives about her dish. A classic example of the patriarchal society in which we live. You didn't feel comfortable sharing displeasure (a feeling) with your "excellent" male (I'm making assumptions) server, Noah, which could have resulted in a different dish or at least a new order of fries. Did you even consider that you could have used the time you spent writing this review asking for new fries?! Maybe your wife would have suggested it if you ever listened to her!
Obviously, I will be giving your review one star (Not good) out of five stars.
Do better.
See you next Tuesday.



Comments